Where You Are We Are®!

Express Mail-In Appraisal

Our Express Mail-In Appraisal service provides you with the convenience of obtaining a jewelry appraisal of the highest quality no matter where you live.


Woman Signing For Package

  • 2 business day turnaround - money-back guarantee
  • Ship items with our reliable, insured shipping partners
  • All appraisals performed by graduate gemologists
  • Accurate appraisals based on current market value
  • Receive notifications and status updates


2 Business Day Guarantee

  • Must use shipping label provided
  • Must ship item(s) in UPS Medium Express Box
  • Must take to local UPS Express Drop Box location or UPS Store before 5:00 p.m. local time
  • Only eligible for items shipped Monday, Tuesday, or Wednesday
  • Must select Next Day Air for return shipment



Prices start at $245. Discounts available for multiple items. Shipping options include 2-day Air, Next Day Air shipping, or Saturday delivery.

Order Now Button

Why Choose Express Mail-in?

The Express Mail-In appraisal service involves an easy to follow process in which each customer’s piece of jewelry receives the highest level of attention and care. Typical retail appraisals are only based on their retail price for the entire piece. The Express Mail-in appraisals are based on the current market value of included gems and precious metals. Each appraisal includes a breakdown of each component with specifications and price.

Heritage Appraisers is a national, independent company who does not engage in the buying or selling of jewelry. We are a jewelry appraisal service and technology company focused on providing accurate and unbiased jewelry appraisals for our customers.

How Does This Work?

After you place your appraisal order online and choose your method of shipping, follow these easy steps:

  • Ship your jewelry items with the shipping label we provide.  We can also provide a box, if necessary.
  • Track updates sent to you via email on the status of your jewelry appraisal.
  • Receive your jewelry and your appraisal shipped with our reliable, insured shipping partner.
  • Access and download your appraisal online anytime.

Now you have the luxury of the most precise, expert-level appraisal on the market. Simply click Get Started to place your order.

Protect your diamond with GEMPRINT®

GEMPRINT®, the world's most sophisticated, non-invasive, and positive identification technology that records the unique optical 'fingerprint' of each diamond, is now available at Heritage Appraisers Inc.'s Beachwood, Ohio Jewelry Appraisal location.

Frequently Asked Questions

What if something happens to my jewelry during the shipping process?
We are fully insured and you can recover the value of your jewelry if it is lost or damaged.


How will I track my jewelry through the Express Mail-in appraisal process?
Yes. You will receive updates on the delivery of your package as well as updates from Heritage when your jewelry is received, appraised, and shipped back out to you.


How is the mail-in service different from the appraisal by appointment?
You can initiate the process online at any time of day, any day of the week. You don’t have to be in the area of one of our affiliates or jewelry store partners. We inspect, clean, and GEMPRINT your jewelry to ensure each piece is beautiful and secure.


What happens if I lose the hard copy of my appraisal?
All of our appraisals are securely stored online for easy access anytime, anywhere.


What are the benefits of adding a GEMPRINT to my jewelry?
With a GEMPRINT you have peace of mind that your diamond can always be identified and verified as your property. Jewelry pieces with a GEMPRINT also earn you discounts on your insurance.